Hem Blogg Sida 11

The limitations of self-selection based innovation systems for increasing regional competitiveness

0

The quest for increasing regional competitiveness by building various kinds of innovation support systems very seldomly takes the people populating these innovation systems enough into account. It is often implicitly assumed that an innovative region’s support system will be amply populated just because it exists. Entrepreneurial individuals are assumed to self-select into the system and take advantage of various support mechanisms. Reality is probably far from this assumed ideal world. The percentage of a population that engages in self-employment activity seldom reaches above single-digit figures, and the quest for increasing this specific figure is often conducted in implicit and ill-defined ways.

Entrepreneurship and enterprise education are often stated to act as a mediator increasing the amount of people choosing an entrepreneurial career in society. The problem is however that to date (to my knowledge) no study on impact of entrepreneurial education has been able to escape the self-selection bias issue, since most entrepreneurial education is voluntary. A recent example is the EU-financed study on “Effects and impact of entrepreneurship programmes in higher education”, conducted by  EIM  Business  &  Policy  Research in Netherlands (featuring Chalmers and 8 other higher education institutions deemed to be of high standard). The authors briefly comment on the self-selection bias issue, and state that “the latitude of the bias seems to be small considering the relatively limited differences in personal characteristics prior to higher education”. As so often, a very discomforting handling of this crucial issue.

This issue is one reason I find venture creation programs so interesting from a societal impact perspective. They cross the border between voluntary venture creation and mandatory curriculum-based activities. Not that this kind of programs are mandatory to anyone, but because many of those signing up for this kind of programs probably don’t understand what kind of transformative journey they have signed up for, thereby increasing the amount of people that get an opportunity to try out entrepreneurship without having to take the risky plunge into the usual voluntary extra-curricular support systems designed for those that have already taken the leap of faith.

I think that we need to supply more opportunities for people to discover an entrepreneurial way of doing things in life both by starting companies and by doing other kinds of action-based value creation activities in educational settings. But then we need more ample access than today to the core educational activities that a majority of our populations are required to attend to. Only then will we be able to escape the single-digit figures of population share choosing an entrepreneurial career. Today we only expose single-digit share of the population for even the slightest chance to be contaminated by the entrepreneurial bug.

This is a flaw of most innovation policy work today I fear. One light in the darkness was seen in my home country of Sweden recently, when a national innovation strategy was decided upon by the Swedish government that actually puts the individual in focus rather than all other things usually focused upon – technology, patents, capital, systems, organisations, etc etc etc (long list). This has potential to lead to concrete activities aiming at changing people’s mindsets before it is too late.

After all, show me an example when entrepreneurial value was created without involving people… Trying to positively influence people’s attitudes to entrepreneurial ways of life through the educational system might be worth increased efforts, provided that the poitical aims are justified. And since when is education free from politics? It just simply isn’t, so why pretend it is?

Folder describing venture creation programs uploaded for the IEEC conference in UK

0

Having been invited to join the IEEC conference by video link, I take the opportunity to share with you the folder we produced in connection with the Entrepreneurial Learning Forum in June 2012 in Gothenburg. We had the pleasure of reveiving guests from VCPs all around the world at this conference, and the discussions were truly inspirating! Here is the folder:

Venture Creation Programs – 14 case descriptions in USA and Europe

Using value creation and the quest for immortality as a way to put learning on steroids

0

Thank you Kieran Egan for putting me on the right track to the next step in my PhD thesis process. It took three years to find this turn in my personal roller-coaster. Egan eloquently argues here that trying to understand human learning only from a “human nature” psychological perspective is bound to fail. We need to consider the tools that bring the human mind to life, what he calls “cognitive tools”, or “cultural-cognitive tools”. So what are the tools I study? Well, two major cognitive tools boosting learning that are frequently used in entrepreneurship education are 1) the (giving) birth of/to a legal entity, and 2) the notion of creating (new kinds of) value for other people. Combined, this for example gives us the “start-up scene” or any variation of it. The minute you invite students to this cultural-cognitive life-world, and invite them to act in it as if it were theirs, it often resonates within them and every related disciplinary subject has a potential to spring to life, and give learning a completely new dimension. I have witnessed it myself, and my fellow alumni tell me the same story consistently.

1) The giving birth to a legal entity (potentially of a revolutionary kind) resonates with our desire to obtain (social) immortality by creating something that transcends ourselves, in an existentialism based way described by Sartre and others.

2) The desire to create value to other people also resonates with basic human desires, i.e. to be useful, quite well described by Emerson:

“The purpose of life is not to be happy. It is to be useful, to be honorable, to be compassionate, to have it make some difference that you have lived and lived well.”

Now, if we combine these two immensely powerful “cultural-cognitive tools” (1 and 2) and insert them into an educational context (and really make them work, which takes a lot of fine-tuning), it gives the life-changing and transformative learning experience that we can observe at the very few venture creation programs that exist around the world. But if we want to find the general implications for learning and education from these rare programs, we cannot escape, omit or disregard the powerful cultural-cognitive tools that surround this kind of programs, they are as important to consider as the human mind and brain driving the learning process. This is an immensely important point made by Kieran Egan. For which I thank him!

Transformative learning offers new insights for entrepreneurship educators

0

It is becoming increasingly apparent to me that the theory on transformative learning pioneered by Jack Mezirow and followed by a giant heap of other researchers (a dozen books, hundreds of papers and around 150 dissertations have been produced, according to Kitchenham here) is a very interesting path to explore more in-depth when trying to understand what goes on in  entrepreneurship education, and especially venture creation programs and other intensive entrepreneurial educational experiences. The links between transformative learning and entrepreneurship education seem to be very scarce. In an upcoming conference on transformative learning in San Fransisco (link), there is only one out of more than 100 speakers that seems to cross-over between these two domains, and that is a Greek researcher named Alexandros Kakouris. I have come across his name before, as he is also into game based learning (see here), yet another domain that has interesting insights potentially on offer for entrepreneurship educators.

One of the (or The) most cited books by Jack Mezirow is “Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning”, with 3833 citations according to Google Scholar, see here. This book contains a lot of links to emotions, another hot topic for my inquiries (read about my literature review on this topic here). One idea that emerged from reading parts of this book is that the old saying that “Repetion is the key to learning”, might be adjusted to “Repetion and emotion are the keys to learning”. This is a nice quote from Mezirow pointing in this direction (p.36):

“The stronger the affective (emotional) dimension of an interpretation and the more frequently it is made, the easier it is to remember.”.

This means that we should strive not only to make our students repeat things we want them to learn, but also try obtaining high levels of emotionality (both positive and negative) in our courses and programs, in order to increase their retention rate of what we try to teach them, and thus increase the chances of reaching desired learning outcomes of an eduational intervention.

Are there more interesting links between entrepreneurship education and transformative learning out there?

Just finished my literature review on emotions in entrepreneurship education

0

Last thing before vacation started I finalized an article to the ISBE research conference coming up in Dublin in November. The article describes the results of my 1,5 year quite extensive literature searches on the topic of emotions in entrepreneurship education (and the related topic of emotions in education in general). When searching for articles treating entrepreneurship AND emotions AND education AND learning, only 22 articles showed up! A field in its infancy thus! (mind the gap…)

I conclude in the article that there seems to be an emotional revolution going on in psychology that has not yet reached the domain of entrepreneurship education. The field of entrepreneurship education is also largely disconnected from the emotional aspects discussed in the fields of psychology, education, neuroscience and creativity. The only relevant scholar outside of entrepreneurship education quoted widely is David Kolb, and his most famous book was published almost 30 years ago! The world has moved on, and there is more developed thinking out there that does not seem to be used almost at all. My own favourite is Peter Jarvis, whose quite (but not very) recent “comprehensive theory on human learning” puts equal emphasis on thoughts, actions and emotions (which is very VERY unusual), and offers a wide range of interesting angles to human learning which are very relevant to entrepreneurship education. I also conclude that many slightly lazy (or uninterested) scholars quote Kolb or Gibb, and that’s it, they don’t dig any deeper. Gibb is one of my own favourites, but the world did not become complete with his work. There are more things to uncover out there, such as the comprehensive work by Dewey which is not very frequently cited. We need to dig deeper and much more outside our own domain if we are to advance the field, I think. Some leading scholars outside the entrepreneurship domain that showed up in my review were Andy Hargreaves, Arlie Hochschild, Jennifer Nias, Reihard Pekrun and Michalinos Zembylas. These I will study even more soon, it seems I have just scratched the surface.

What is your take on the theme of emotions in entrepreneurship education?

Thank you!

0

We have now lived through our first Entrepreneurial Learning Forum, which has mainly focused on Venture Creation Programs, and we are positively overwelmed and overjoyed. The past two days have given us at Chalmers and I hope our emerging VCP community a sense of family, legitimacy and importance above and beyond what we have experienced in isolation up to now. We will be in the near and more distant future be complementing this and other forums (ex. on Linked in or Facebook) with content and contributions, but for now, we would just like to say THANK YOU to all the ELF participants and welcome to the family! ‘Woof woof” and ‘cling cling’!! Karen (speaking, unanchored for Mats, Martin, Viktor and the rest)

Overwhelmed by Entrepreneurial Learning Forum

0

Wow, what a fantastic group of people that came from all over the world to Gothenburg to discuss venture creation programs at our forum focusing on the entrepreneurial learning that occurs at these unique programs! As someone said, “I have never before been in an international conference where we so quickly came down to discussing core issues, without getting stuck at definitional discussions”. It was evident that the people managing and championing these programs had very much in common, despite being quite a heterogenous group in many ways – region-wise, size of institutions, backgrounds, theory vs practice orientation etc etc. Someone asked if we just had invited our friends, because of the family-like atmosphere that quickly developed, but actually quite few of the participants had met before at all. Or as one of the American program managers said to one of the others from US: “How come we haven’t heard of you before?!”.

One of the results of this milestone conference is that we now are determined to keep this global community going by creating a network entity facilitating further collaboration and exchange. We at Chalmers will try to lead this development, but it is now evident that it will be a truly collective endeavour since everybody has so much to gain from collaborating in this unique group of people / programs. We will all try to meet again in one year, either at one of the participating institutions or in connection with EURAM in Istanbul in June 2013, where Chalmers will be hosting a track on Entrepreneurial Behaviour.

Here is a list of participating institutions:

Aalto University
Babson College
Chalmers University of Technology
Colorado State University
Coventry University
Lund University
North Carolina State University
University of Buckingham
University of Gothenburg
University of Huddersfield
University of Tromsö
University of Texas at Austin

Keynote-ing on conference in Mikkeli, Finland

1

A couple of weeks ago I was in Mikkeli, Finland, to talk about how to build entrepreneurial ecosystems through action-based education. It was the yearly conference for the SPACE-EU network, a quite large network of educators in international business and language. They have recently begun to explore the area of entrepreneurial education, and have a working group that is investigating this on behalf of their members, read more here. At first, I thought that they must have mistakenly asked a PhD student to be a keynote speaker. But when I got there, it was obvious that they knew very well what we are doing at Chalmers and they were very interested in hearing more about it. So I talked about the entrepreneurial gap between academic life and the outside world, about venture creation programs as an entity that can bridge the gap, and about opportunities to generalize beyond venture creation programs within the area of entrepreneurial learning and teaching. It was very well received indeed, to my slight surprise! Actually this network has as one of its mission statements to “facilitating the bridging of the gap between higher education institutions and the business community and key stakeholders. “. So after having read that, I am not so surprised anymore. Very nice to meet new friends in this endeavour!

Entrepreneurial Learning Forum 2012 approaching

0

We are now in the final stage of planning the inaugural Entrepreneurial Learning Forum, and we are very excited indeed! 75% of the programs we have invited are actually coming to Gothenburg in Sweden to meet us and the Swedish summer. We have sent out a survey to the around 30 confirmed participants in order to find out more about what they are interested in discussing. All but one have responded, and we now know what this very unique group of people are both more and less interested in. I can now reveal the three most common topics of interest to the participants. Within entrepreneurial context the most interesting subject is Dual Missions, or “How can both educational and venture creation ambitions be achieved simultaneously?”. Within entrepreneurial teaching the most interesting subject is Action vs Knowledge, or “How is the action-based part of the education integrated into knowledge development?”. Withing entrepreneurial learning the most interesting subject is Initiative, or “How do you get your students to take own initiatives to interact with people outside your program?”. We will discuss these and many other issues on 12-13:th of June at the inaugural forum. We expect it to be the starting point of a very active and dynamic global community of action-based educators.

First asian venture creation program discovered

0

This week I have investigated a potential venture creation program in Singapore, and it indeed seems that they let the students start real ventures as formal part of the program. They even use business ideas from other universities, notably University of Washington in Seattle, USA. This is the first instance of a venture creation program I have seen having a structure for using intellectual property from another university and part of the world in their program. But probably not the last! It remains to be seen how exactly this is done, and I have tried to contact the people responsible. The problem in my investigations with Asia is that the language barrier is higher, but I will get the opportunity to try Google Translate to its limits. And I am also searching in the very good book about entrepreneurship education in Asia recently released by Edward Elgar. We have also invited Nanyang Technological University to our Entrepreneurial Learning Forum in June 2012 where we are inviting all confirmed VCPs we can find.